Ask a tradesperson
Gas Work
Should i replace gas fire with electric?
我有一个小客厅那老气体火灾t needs replacing. I can't decide if I should replace it with another gas fire or go for an electric fire. Can you offer any advice? I have fgch so only need it as an extra boost for particularly cold days or just for cool nights in the summer when I don't want the heating on.
Thank you in anticipation of your help.
2 Answers from MyBuilder Gas Engineers
Best Answer
R&B Plumbing and Heating Services Ltd
Sheffield•Member since 15 Dec 2015•21jobs,95%positivefeedback
Hi, here's a few things to consider when replacing a gas fire.
Condition of chimney:
Is the chimney in good or bad condition? As a gas safe engineer I am required to carry out a test using smoke bombs to determine if the chimney has the right amount of 'pull' to get rid of the fumes. Should this fail, you will need a new flue liner which could be costly and sometimes rather destructive. Should it pass on the other hand, all you need is the right fire to suit your requirements.
Builders opening:
Is the condition of the builders opening good or bad? This is the square hole if you like where the fire is positioned at the bottom of the chimney, this will require investigation prior to your new fire being installed for cracks and weaknesses where fumes could escape back into the room. If this fails it would need properly rectifying with fire cement and any weak spots testing. Should this be ok, again all you need is your new fire.
Ventilation:
Checks are required to ensure the room has adequate ventilation to support your fire. Should this be ok, again you would just need the new fire.
电气火灾:
If you opt for an electric fire, they certainly are not as warm as gas fires and would require your builders opening to have a vent in order to stop damp issues. In some cases depending on the gas engineer, you may require an electrician if there is no power nearby. They look really nice but aren't as warm.
Summary:
All in all, I would recommend a gas fire if its the heat you require not design (as you have stated) but, ensure you have a gas safe registered engineer with experience quote you for the works and talk you through these important steps. Your life could be at risk of carbon monoxide poisoning if you get the wrong engineer. Always ask for gas safe ID.
Hope this is helpful,
Regards,
Brett Grayson.
R&B Plumbing & Heating Services LTD.
Answered 9th Jun 2016
Sutton Coldfield•Member since 18 Jul 2016•15jobs,93%positivefeedback
As above it depends on what is found once the old fire is removed. I would ask someone to disconnect the old fire and then advise on you options once they have accessed the chimney.
Answered 18th Jul 2016
Related Questions
- i want to replace a gas fire. Will a gas engineer be able to buy the model i like or do I have to go to a gas fire shop.
- i have cental heating in my house and i want a gas fire, i have no chimney or ventilation so i have been told i need a flueless gas fire how do i get a flue fitted
- Gas fire replaced with electric fire - How to vent?
I am going to have the gas fire taken out of the lounge and I have bought an electric fire and surround from B&Q to replace it. I...
- Can I Replace A Flueless Gas Fire With A Balanced Flue Gas Fire?
I currently have a flueless gas fire which has been disconnected, as it was deemed dangerous and needed servicing. I tried to get...
Post your job to find high quality tradespeople and get free quotes
Question Categories
- All Questions
- Architectural Services
- Bathroom Fitting
- Bricklaying
- Carpentry & Joinery
- Carpet & Lino
- Central Heating
- Chimneys & Fireplaces
- Conservatories
- Conversions - General
- Damp Proofing
- Demolition & Waste Clearance
- Driveways
- Electrical
- Extensions
- Fascias, Soffits & Guttering
- Fencing
- Gas Work
- Groundwork & Foundations
- Handyman
- Hard Flooring
- Insulation
- Kitchen Fitting
- Landscape Gardening
- Locksmiths
- Loft Conversions
- New Builds
- Painting & Decorating
- Plastering
- Plumbing
- Restoration & Refurbishment
- Roofing
- Security Systems
- Stonemasonry
- Tiling
- Tree Surgery
- Windows